Vacation Rentals in Monticello, Indiana

25 Properties Available

Waterfront Lake Shafer - Hot Tub + Fireplace Private vacation home
Waterfront Lake Shafer - Hot Tub + Fireplace
$749 / night
View Details
Lakeside Bliss: Spectacular Lake Views and Access! Private vacation home
Lakeside Bliss: Spectacular Lake Views and Access!
$492 / night
View Details
Unit #4 (Buffett Bungalow) Private vacation home
Unit #4 (Buffett Bungalow)
$463 / night
View Details
Monticello Vacation Rental w/ Private Boat Dock! Private vacation home
Monticello Vacation Rental w/ Private Boat Dock!
$447 / night
View Details
The Main Lake House - Lake Front - Lake Freeman - Patio, Fire Pit , Dock, Grill Private vacation home
The Main Lake House - Lake Front - Lake Freeman - Patio, Fire Pit , Dock, Grill
$376 / night
View Details
Spacious Two-Bedroom House with Lake Views Apartment
Spacious Two-Bedroom House with Lake Views
$370 / night
View Details
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities! Private vacation home
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
$360 / night
View Details
Spacious Two-Bedroom Cabin 9 Cabin
Spacious Two-Bedroom Cabin 9
$345 / night
View Details
Newly Remodeled Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront Private vacation home
Newly Remodeled Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront
$308 / night
View Details
Cozy Two Bedroom Lakeview Cabin 1 Cabin
Cozy Two Bedroom Lakeview Cabin 1
$278 / night
View Details
Cozy Two Bedroom Lakeview Cabin 2 Cabin
Cozy Two Bedroom Lakeview Cabin 2
$278 / night
View Details
Cozy Two Bedroom Lakeview Cabin 3 Cabin
Cozy Two Bedroom Lakeview Cabin 3
$278 / night
View Details
Lakeside Cottage w/ Spacious Multi-level Deck and Outdoor Living Space Cottage
Lakeside Cottage w/ Spacious Multi-level Deck and Outdoor Living Space
$263 / night
View Details
Unit 6 on the water 2 queen beds Apartment
Unit 6 on the water 2 queen beds
$260 / night
View Details
Year round Lake home w\/wonderful frontage, nice yard w\/ fire pit, home theatre Private vacation home
Year round Lake home w\/wonderful frontage, nice yard w\/ fire pit, home theatre
$252 / night
View Details
Charming One Bedroom Cabin 5 Cabin
Charming One Bedroom Cabin 5
$241 / night
View Details
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #1 RV Retreat Villa Mobile home
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #1 RV Retreat Villa
$210 / night
View Details
Enjoy a serene stay at Eagle Nest Cottage Cottage
Enjoy a serene stay at Eagle Nest Cottage
$194 / night
View Details
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #2 RV Reggae Reef Villa Mobile home
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #2 RV Reggae Reef Villa
$158 / night
View Details
2BR Room at Alexander’s Landing. Walk to Indiana Beach + Pool Access Hotel
2BR Room at Alexander’s Landing. Walk to Indiana Beach + Pool Access
$151 / night
View Details
Great 2 Bedroom Family Apt right across from Indiana Beach Apartment
Great 2 Bedroom Family Apt right across from Indiana Beach
$151 / night
View Details
Family Friendly completely remodeled secluded vacation spot near Lake Shafer Private vacation home
Family Friendly completely remodeled secluded vacation spot near Lake Shafer
$150 / night
View Details
Firefly at Lake Shafer Cottage
Firefly at Lake Shafer
$140 / night
View Details
Monticello Vacation Rental w\/ Private Boat Dock! Cottage
Monticello Vacation Rental w\/ Private Boat Dock!
$0 / night
View Details
Paradise Cove Lakeside Cottages Cottage
Paradise Cove Lakeside Cottages
$0 / night
View Details