Vacation Rentals in New Buffalo, Michigan

50 Properties Available

Luxury Estate with 3 Homes, Pool, Hot Tubs, Basketball/Tennis Court near Lake Private vacation home
Luxury Estate with 3 Homes, Pool, Hot Tubs, Basketball/Tennis Court near Lake
$3286 / night
View Details
2027 NOW OPEN! Luxurious New Buffalo Rental Has It All! Private vacation home
2027 NOW OPEN! Luxurious New Buffalo Rental Has It All!
$2561 / night
View Details
Juniper Presents: Lakefront Home w\/ Prvate Beach, Lg Yard, Stunning Views All-ar Private vacation home
Juniper Presents: Lakefront Home w\/ Prvate Beach, Lg Yard, Stunning Views All-ar
$1556 / night
View Details
Family Estate\/heated pool\/short walk to beach\/playground\/golf\/basketball\/tennis Private vacation home
Family Estate\/heated pool\/short walk to beach\/playground\/golf\/basketball\/tennis
$1555 / night
View Details
Blue Laguna Retreat - Private Beach 5 min - Hot tub - Riverfront - 20+ guests Private vacation home
Blue Laguna Retreat - Private Beach 5 min - Hot tub - Riverfront - 20+ guests
$1450 / night
View Details
Family Friendly Oasis With Private Pool, Hot Tub, and Game Room - Close to Town Private vacation home
Family Friendly Oasis With Private Pool, Hot Tub, and Game Room - Close to Town
$1184 / night
View Details
Grand Beach getaway with year-round pool, hot tub & sauna! Private vacation home
Grand Beach getaway with year-round pool, hot tub & sauna!
$1164 / night
View Details
2027 OPEN! NEW BUFFALO HOME CLOSE TO BEACH & DOWNTOWN! Private vacation home
2027 OPEN! NEW BUFFALO HOME CLOSE TO BEACH & DOWNTOWN!
$1100 / night
View Details
Oasis In The Woods With Heated Pool Private vacation home
Oasis In The Woods With Heated Pool
$1027 / night
View Details
New Buffalo Retreat by the Beach Private vacation home
New Buffalo Retreat by the Beach
$863 / night
View Details
Poolside Bliss! Private Beach! Renovated home w\/ pool & 5 min cart ride to beach Private vacation home
Poolside Bliss! Private Beach! Renovated home w\/ pool & 5 min cart ride to beach
$850 / night
View Details
Pool is OPEN! Juniper Presents: Lakefront Dream Home-HotTub, 2 Fab Decks+Firepit Private vacation home
Pool is OPEN! Juniper Presents: Lakefront Dream Home-HotTub, 2 Fab Decks+Firepit
$821 / night
View Details
Luxury vacation cottage - walk to downtown New Buffalo, beach, and heated pool! Private vacation home
Luxury vacation cottage - walk to downtown New Buffalo, beach, and heated pool!
$765 / night
View Details
Beach house with Private Heated Pool, Jacuzzi, Firepit. Steps to beach and park. Private vacation home
Beach house with Private Heated Pool, Jacuzzi, Firepit. Steps to beach and park.
$722 / night
View Details
Lodged in the Trees Lk Retreat - POOL and HOT TUB! Private vacation home
Lodged in the Trees Lk Retreat - POOL and HOT TUB!
$650 / night
View Details
Peaceful New Buffalo Home: Walk to Lake Michigan! Private vacation home
Peaceful New Buffalo Home: Walk to Lake Michigan!
$634 / night
View Details
5 Blocks To The Beach ~ 2 Blocks To Downtown ~ Walk To Everything! Private vacation home
5 Blocks To The Beach ~ 2 Blocks To Downtown ~ Walk To Everything!
$620 / night
View Details
WAYA's DEN: Riverfront - Hot tub - Fire Pit - Private Setting - Close to Town Cabin
WAYA's DEN: Riverfront - Hot tub - Fire Pit - Private Setting - Close to Town
$613 / night
View Details
2025 Open! New Buffalo Home With Private Heated Pool and Hot Tub! Private vacation home
2025 Open! New Buffalo Home With Private Heated Pool and Hot Tub!
$577 / night
View Details
Juniper Presents: Lakefront Getaway and Outdoor Living Redefined Private vacation home
Juniper Presents: Lakefront Getaway and Outdoor Living Redefined
$550 / night
View Details
Wolfsbane - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa at Petite Acres Villa
Wolfsbane - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa at Petite Acres
$548 / night
View Details
Quiet neighborhood Blks to town/beach fenced yard Private vacation home
Quiet neighborhood Blks to town/beach fenced yard
$530 / night
View Details
Juniper Presents: Elegant-Comfy Fmly Getwy, Pool Access,Porch w\/ Pond+Pool Views Private vacation home
Juniper Presents: Elegant-Comfy Fmly Getwy, Pool Access,Porch w\/ Pond+Pool Views
$526 / night
View Details
Captain’s House -BEST Location Downtown! New Buffalo - Walk Everywhere - xl park Private vacation home
Captain’s House -BEST Location Downtown! New Buffalo - Walk Everywhere - xl park
$524 / night
View Details
Private Setting - Close to Beach, Shops, Restaurants and the Casino Agritourism
Private Setting - Close to Beach, Shops, Restaurants and the Casino
$519 / night
View Details
Heated Private Pool, Spacious, Hot Tub All Year Private vacation home
Heated Private Pool, Spacious, Hot Tub All Year
$499 / night
View Details
Modern Cottage \"M\" Luxury home w\/hot tub, community pool-walk to town & beach Cottage
Modern Cottage \"M\" Luxury home w\/hot tub, community pool-walk to town & beach
$482 / night
View Details
Designer Downtown Home-Rooftop Deck w Lake Views Private vacation home
Designer Downtown Home-Rooftop Deck w Lake Views
$478 / night
View Details
Blue Laguna Cottage - Private Beach 5 min - Riverfront - Kayaks Private vacation home
Blue Laguna Cottage - Private Beach 5 min - Riverfront - Kayaks
$474 / night
View Details
Juniper Presents: Terrific VacayHome-Lke MI Vws, Elgant Decor,2 Firplcs, Sunroom Private vacation home
Juniper Presents: Terrific VacayHome-Lke MI Vws, Elgant Decor,2 Firplcs, Sunroom
$469 / night
View Details
3BR 2b New Buff cottage dogs ok, steps to dwntn restaurants&shops, walk to beach Cottage
3BR 2b New Buff cottage dogs ok, steps to dwntn restaurants&shops, walk to beach
$466 / night
View Details
Farmesque with a splash of modern Private vacation home
Farmesque with a splash of modern
$451 / night
View Details
Large 3 BR w/ two pools, parking - near everything Condo
Large 3 BR w/ two pools, parking - near everything
$426 / night
View Details
New Buffalo. Walkable, Completely Remodeled, Fenced Yard Private vacation home
New Buffalo. Walkable, Completely Remodeled, Fenced Yard
$402 / night
View Details
Modern Farmhouse - steps from downtown and the beach!! Private vacation home
Modern Farmhouse - steps from downtown and the beach!!
$383 / night
View Details
Spacious house with amazing back yard 10 min from the beach Private vacation home
Spacious house with amazing back yard 10 min from the beach
$372 / night
View Details
Charming Downtown NB Cottage w Guest home, Walk to Beach! Private vacation home
Charming Downtown NB Cottage w Guest home, Walk to Beach!
$354 / night
View Details
Cottage Retreat close to downtown New Buffalo. Sleeps 12, Pet friendly + Games! Cottage
Cottage Retreat close to downtown New Buffalo. Sleeps 12, Pet friendly + Games!
$350 / night
View Details
3BR Condo Close To The Beach! Condo
3BR Condo Close To The Beach!
$348 / night
View Details
'Stones Throw' Lakeside Home - Walk to Marina + Assoc Beach Private vacation home
'Stones Throw' Lakeside Home - Walk to Marina + Assoc Beach
$343 / night
View Details
Spacious Family Townhome W\/ Pool, Beach Access, Fast WiFi & Central AC Private vacation home
Spacious Family Townhome W\/ Pool, Beach Access, Fast WiFi & Central AC
$341 / night
View Details
New Private Pool Opening May 2023, Hot Tub, Renovated Home, Ping Pong Table! Private vacation home
New Private Pool Opening May 2023, Hot Tub, Renovated Home, Ping Pong Table!
$338 / night
View Details
The Cobblestone House Private vacation home
The Cobblestone House
$335 / night
View Details
Quiet neighborhood home Hot tub Fire pit Large deck Bar blocks to brewery Private vacation home
Quiet neighborhood home Hot tub Fire pit Large deck Bar blocks to brewery
$332 / night
View Details
Luxury Downtown Getaway: 2BR Condo Near New Buffalo’s Top Attractions! Apartment
Luxury Downtown Getaway: 2BR Condo Near New Buffalo’s Top Attractions!
$330 / night
View Details
Peach by the Beach! 1 Bdrm Apt close to downtown Apartment
Peach by the Beach! 1 Bdrm Apt close to downtown
$283 / night
View Details
Michiana Heated Pool Retreat | Fire Pit, Fireplace, ~1 Mile to the Beach Private vacation home
Michiana Heated Pool Retreat | Fire Pit, Fireplace, ~1 Mile to the Beach
$282 / night
View Details
Walk Downtown, Huge Hot tub, Coffee on the Porch! Private vacation home
Walk Downtown, Huge Hot tub, Coffee on the Porch!
$277 / night
View Details
Characterful home near beach with private hot tub, pool, & firepit Private vacation home
Characterful home near beach with private hot tub, pool, & firepit
$276 / night
View Details
Walk to Beach & Stray Dog! Cute Downtown Cottage Cottage
Walk to Beach & Stray Dog! Cute Downtown Cottage
$272 / night
View Details