Vacation Rentals in Montauk, New York

50 Properties Available

Private vacation home

Breathtaking Ocean Front Property

$13586 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Modernist Montauk Home with Heated Pool, Close to Lake Montauk and Ditch...

$5054 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Spacious 5-bedroom Waterfront House on Beautiful Montauk Lake - Newly renovated

$4964 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

5 Bed Amagansett Dunes Luxury w/ Pool + Elevator + 2 Min walk to private beach

$4286 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Ocean views + pool, on private road with short walk to beach.

$3500 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Montauk Oceanfront Beach House - directly on the beach in Hither Hills

$3233 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Brand New Renovated Modern Ditch Plains Oasis- One Block Walk to Beach

$3000 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

High End Hither Hills Beach House 3 mins to sand

$2869 / night

View Details

Villa

7 Bedroom Villa Retreat Overlooking Lake Montauk

$2657 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Beautiful 5 BR Montauk House with Private Lake Montauk Beach!

$2547 / night

View Details

$What You Have! Eat, Swim, Scenic Montauk. Hither Hills St. Park to \"The Point\"$ Private vacation home

What You Have! Eat, Swim, Scenic Montauk. Hither Hills St. Park to \"The Point\"

$2514 / night

View Details

$New Home w\/Amazing Sunset Views on East Lake ~ Every Amenity$ Private vacation home

New Home w\/Amazing Sunset Views on East Lake ~ Every Amenity

$2314 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Brand New Montauk Beach House

$2307 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Great central location, new constructionheated gunite saltwaterpool

$2300 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Modern Montauk Beach House

$2300 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Large Montauk Home With Pool Off East Lake Sunset View

$2264 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Montauk - Beachfront

$2193 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Ideal Montauk retreat with pool and hottub

$2188 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Perfect Family Retreat With Ocean Views, Heated Pool, And Private Beach Access!

$1933 / night

View Details

$Ocean Views! Stone's Throw to Beach\/Town! Newly Renovated 4 BR!$ Private vacation home

Ocean Views! Stone's Throw to Beach\/Town! Newly Renovated 4 BR!

$1923 / night

View Details

$Ocean Views w\/ NEW Heated Pool, Hot Tub & Walk to Beach, Town$ Private vacation home

Ocean Views w\/ NEW Heated Pool, Hot Tub & Walk to Beach, Town

$1751 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Hither Hills - Family friendly, Multi-generational Montauk Retreat

$1636 / night

View Details

$Great Location - 3 BR \/ 1 BA, Pond Front - Perfect Getaway House$ Private vacation home

Great Location - 3 BR \/ 1 BA, Pond Front - Perfect Getaway House

$1625 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Walk to the Ditch Plains Beach from this 6 bedroom Spacious Modern Surf House!!

$1590 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Montauk 5 Bedroom Beach House with Pool and Great Ocean Views

$1560 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Spacious Modern Home for up to 2 families, Pool, Hot Tub, 10 min walk to beach

$1534 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

DITCH PLAINS HEATED POOL, SPECTACULAR OCEAN VIEWS

$1520 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Oceanfront Home In Downtown Montauk!!! Private Ocean Beach Path!!

$1517 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Newly built private and spacious Montauk home

$1500 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Steps to Ditch Plains Beach, Newly Renovated with Water Views!

$1462 / night

View Details

$Montauk Hither Hills Ocean View ,1 block to beach\nrental registry #21-750$ Private vacation home

Montauk Hither Hills Ocean View ,1 block to beach\nrental registry #21-750

$1460 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Montauk 4bd/3.5ba Ocean, Private beach, pool and spa!

$1432 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

NEWLY RENOVATED HITHER HILLS HOME W POOL - FAMILIES ONLY - HH BEACH RIGHTS

$1430 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Walk to beach and town from this sunny family home with large deck.

$1391 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

REAL Montauk w/ pool, hot tub, high design in the heart of Montauk. Pets! View

$1356 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Spacious Montauk Home Minutes to Ditch Plains Beach and Montauk Point...

$1328 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Walk to town and beach

$1312 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Fabulous Beach Front Home

$1297 / night

View Details

$Newly Renovated, 4BR home w\/ Private Bay Beach Rights$ Private vacation home

Newly Renovated, 4BR home w\/ Private Bay Beach Rights

$1293 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Idyllic Serene and Secluded Ocean Retreat in Ideal location!

$1288 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Oasis at The End

$1283 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Delightful 4-bedroom house with VIEW in Montauk! LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION!!!

$1258 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Beautiful, spacious, newly renovated house close to Ditch plains

$1253 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

MONTAUK Perfect Family and Friends Getaway

$1250 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Short walk away from Ditch Plains Beach! Spacious cozy Montauk Beach House

$1233 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Huge private house, IG heated pool, fire pit, sleeps 10, 5 bath,Walk to Gurneys!

$1232 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Modern Montauk Marvel

$1218 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Bright 4 BR house 1 mile from beach and 3 mins from town

$1194 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Beautiful ditch plains beach house

$1100 / night

View Details

Private vacation home

Spacious Brand New Home in Lovely Quiet Neighborhood

$1092 / night

View Details